This years draft has certainly garnered a lot mixed reactions. I saw the Eagles draft grade range from a optimistic A- to a dismal F-. I think the Kolb pick really threw off alot of draftniks like the almighty Kiper. It's hard for some of these guys to believe that NFL teams actually know better than them....which of course they do (see Kiper's raving about Mike Williams in the '05 draft). I think our draft was a solid B+ and I'll tell you why.
The Eagles

Going into the draft, the Eagles had a laundry list of positions that needed to be addressed that read something like this: Safety, Cornerback, Defensive End, Running Back, Inside Linebacker, Outside Linebacker, Tight End (NO NOT WR). Very few people thought the Eagles would go for a QB, especially not early. I believe the Eagles wanted to select a safety first, either Merriweather, Nelson, or Griffin. The problem is, the Titans threw everyone off by selecting Griffin so early (pick 19...where's Merril Hodge to call out the Titans this year? Oh right he's commentating for the AFL now. Sucka!). This really screwed over the Eagles because NE and Jacksonville, who picked just before us, both had needs at Safety. With the top safeties off the board at 26, the Eagles were in a pickle. Now, apparently Kolb was the highest rated pick on the Eagles board at the time....can you imagine if we had taken him at 26?? Fortunately we didn't and wisely traded down to pick up a high 2nd rounder and an extra 3rd and 5th (good value). This trade set us up to grab Kolb (controversial yes, but I'll discuss him later), OLB Stewart Bradely, and S C.J. Gaddis. I'm willing to bet the combined contribution of these 3 guys will outweigh Spencer's. We also picked up DE Victor Abiamiri, RB Tony Hunt, TE Brent Celek (who???), CB Rashard Barskdale (WHO??), and the bowling ball of a man RB Nate Ilaoa. Aside from a safety who is a guarantee to immediately contribute, the Eagles filled all their holes: a DE and SAM linebacker who can contribute immediately, the big(ger) back that every one's been screaming for forever, depth in the secondary, and another TE. And Kolb provides insurance for the suddenly injury prone (like it or not) McNabb. B+
Really, the best way to judge how well the Eagles did is to compare our draft to those of our division opponents:
The (god damn) Cowboys

Many people have raved about the Cowboys moves on draft day which saw them picking up DE Anthony Spencer on the first day and getting an extra 1st rounder in '08. I think the Eagles actually got a better deal in their trade with Boys, but than the Browns had to come in and offer up some ludicrous offer to tag their poster boy Quinn. The Browns made Dallas look reallll smart, but I don't think they did as well as it might seem. Spencer may well turn into a good DE, but he is far from a lock for defensive rookie of the year....there is a reason 4 other DE's were taken before him. Two of the Cowboys major problems last year were the offensive line and secondary....neither of which Spencer will help. Dallas did pick up two OT's in the 2nd and 4th rounds but they didn't address the secondary at all until the 7th round! Money! Eagles fans will surely remember Roy Williams and Pat Watkins getting beat by our long ball all day last year. They added S Ken Hamlin in free agency, but he is a SS in the Michael Lewis mold, perhaps even more of a liability than Williams in coverage. I'd say the Cowboys scored a solid B- in the draft simply because they did not address a serious issue (thankfully).
The Giants

The Giants biggest mistake of the off-season was keeping Tom Caughlin around for another year that is sure to be tumultuous. Tiki is gone and all the weight of the Giants offense is now squarely on Eli's shaky shoulders. Word. The Giants used their first two picks on CB Aaron Ross and WR Steve Smith. Ross may help a shaky secondary (see Stallworth turning Sam Madison inside and out) and help with the return game but I'm not sold on him being an every down corner...the Texas secondary (despite the presence of Michael Griffin and Ross) gave up a lot of yards last year. Smith is redundant because they used a high pick on Sinorice Moss last year and Toomer and Burress are still around... The most important area that needed improvement for the Giants was clearly their offensive line (perhaps a reason why Eli always looks so scared). The Giants, however, did not address the OL at all in this years draft until the 6th round! Let the Little Manning bashing begin...
C-
The Redskins (yes they were at the draft)

It is hard to believe it but the Redskins have yet to acquire ANY overpriced free-agents this off-season! They must be stockpiling picks for the draft, right?! Wrong! (Enter Dan Snyder, Exit Draft Picks) The Skins had a whopping 5 picks in this years draft. One on the first day. They had numerous problems last year with their offensive line, secondary, and defensive line. So, instead of trading down from the 6th overall pick to try to pick up some more players, they selected S LaRon Landry. Landry will probably be a stud but he can't do anything to help the pass rush or protect Campbell from the opposition. In all the Redskins drafted ZERO linemen. They picked up two LB's, QB Jordan Palmer (Carson's bro...he's even got a brace on the same knee!), and some TE. Awful. I almost feel bad for them...
F
So, in terms of how well our division opponents fared, I think the Eagles made out pretty well.
Coming soon...meet the Eagles' draft picks!
No comments:
Post a Comment